Archives For Book Review

This short book is Lewis’ admittedly fictional account—he was inspired by some sci-fi stories he’d read—of a dream/vision of Heaven and Hell. The story itself is a bit complex, though beautifully written. (Though, keep in mind, Lewis wrote his books sixty-some years ago as an Irishman in England, and the language he uses reflects that.)

The story, however, is merely the vehicle by which Lewis offers the reader some thoughts and ideas he’s had concerning the afterlife. One of the passages I liked best was one in a woman, beautiful and bright, in Heaven tries to convince her husband, a twisted and dwarfish soul, to remain with her in Heaven where he can grow and flourish and be freed from his misery. He rejects her love, the love of Heaven, and the little bit of joy he had tasted in her presence. He tells her that if she really loved him then she would come back with him to Hell. This, of course, does not happen, and the dwarfish figure vanishes, consumed by its own misery and self-pity.

Lewis and his spiritual guide then have a conversation about the scene where Lewis finds it hard that the woman wasn’t touched by her husband’s misery. The love and joy that flowed through the woman, in the face of such suffering from a loved-one, seemed somehow wrong:

‘…Is it really tolerable that she should be untouched by his misery, even his self-made misery?….What some say on Earth is that the final loss of one soul gives the lie to all the joy of those who are saved.’

‘Ye see it does not.’

‘I feel in a way that it ought to.’

‘That sounds very merciful: but see what lurks behind it.’


‘The demand of the loveless and the self-imprisoned that they should be allowed to blackmail the universe: that till they consent to be happy (on their own terms) no one else shall taste joy: that theirs should be the final power; that Hell should be able to veto Heaven….Either the day must come when joy prevails and all the makers of misery are no longer able to infect it: or else for ever and ever the makers of misery can destroy in others the happiness they reject for themselves. I know it has a grand sound to say ye’ll accept no salvation which leaves even one creature in the dark outside. But watch that sophistry or ye’ll make a Dog in a Manger the tyrant of the universe.’

To be honest, I had no idea what that phrase “Dog in a Manger” meant. After a short trip to Wikipedia, I found out the basic idea of the phrase is of someone who guards something of value from others, preventing them from enjoying it, while at the same time refusing to enjoy it himself. Thus, the point is that some will never open themselves up to the love of God—no matter what some might say (Matthew 23:13).

I could go one writing about the various lessons communicated in this book, but the most pertinent one for me was this: Heaven is vastly confounding to the finite mind, and it is good that it is so. If we were now able to understand Heaven in such a way as to say, “It’s like this and that and so on…” then it must not be much of an eternal paradise. The Heaven that Lewis describes is one that is more real, more layered, and more complex than could be understood in a single visit, especially when that visitor is observing Heaven with a still finite of the first creation. If Heaven is for Real is a true account of visiting Heaven, then Heaven must be a fairly simplistic and un-challenging place.

Paul experienced a reality so startling and shattering that he was forbidden to relate the experience to anyone. John was only allowed to relate certain vignettes from his peek behind the veil and even these passages of Scripture are layered in apocalyptic imagery, poetry, symbolism, and incomprehensible prophecy. To point to these passages as literal statements of how Heaven will be at The End—for the Heaven in which we will spend eternity with God after the war has finally been won has not yet been revealed—is to assume too much about the various layers that comprise the text. This is a mistake that many “I went to Heaven” stories make: their Heaven is too small.

Book Review: Heaven is for Real

Phil —  September 17, 2012 — Leave a comment

Heaven is for Real coverHeaven is for real, but this book isn’t.

A lot of people I know and care about have read Heaven is for Real and raved about it, but—and maybe I’m too cynical—after The Shack swept through unchecked in many Christian circles, I decided that I would try to check every book that appears to be gaining a ridiculous amount of popularity. Thus, here I am.


Heaven is for Real is the story of four-year old Colton Burpo’s three minute—but how does time really work in Heaven?—trip to the Great Beyond while his body lay on an operating table suffering from a burst appendix. When Colton returned to Earth and recovered from his medical ordeal, he began to relate to his parents several amazing tales of meeting Jesus and exploring Heaven.

The Good

I don’t want to attribute anything good to this book because I really don’t want people to read it, but since many already have…
Continue Reading…

Good Books on Heaven

Phil —  August 8, 2012 — Leave a comment

I’m looking for some good books about Heaven. I’m reading one right now, and I’ve got a bad waiting in the wings.

Here are three books I have read and found to be very good and very helpful in understanding Heaven and the life that we lead on Earth while we wait for the next world to be revealed.

The Gospel of the Kingdom: Scriptural Studies in the Kingdom of God by George Eldon Ladd

The Great Divorce by CS Lewis

The Slumber of Christianity: Awakening a Passion for Heaven on Earth by Ted Dekker. **Update: While I do agree with the author’s position that we need a greater desire for Heaven, he seems to be positing a spiritual-only Heaven, which I don’t agree.**

I’m aiming to reread these books this year. When I do, I’ll review them on the blog.

Do you have any suggestions for my pile of books?

Summary: “Blessed are the…” is how Jesus began each little verse of what we call the “Beatitudes,” but what if the word we translate as “blessed” is better translated as “lucky”? Sounds a bit scandalous, doesn’t it? If Glenn’s Greek is good—and I’m reasonably sure it is—then there might be a case for this new translation, which serves as the basis for this book’s thesis.

According to Packiam, Jesus took a non-religious, everyday word to communicate the some radical truths that we may have lost sight of due to our translation of “blessed” instead of “lucky.” Perhaps Jesus wasn’t pronouncing blessings on these people so much as He was commenting on their present situation and how it was a blessing to them.
Continue Reading…

Extraordinary by John Bevere

The Summary
God loves us and wants the absolute best for us! He’s provided Heaven for our future, and many people stop there. Bevere contends that because God loves us He wants us to actually enjoy this life on earth! We’re not merely here to just wait for Heaven. We’re alive so that we can truly live! We should be doing extraordinary things for His glory.

The Good
John uses a very accessible and enjoyable writing style. The book reads quickly and easily, which I for one appreciate very much. Also, Bevere is fairly forthcoming with his own shortcomings, struggles with sin, and moments of doubt. It’s refreshing.
Continue Reading…